The BMW M2 Years To Avoid

The BMW M2 has been a fan favorite since its inception. It offers a compact, affordable, and thrilling driving experience. As the smallest and least expensive M car, it has captured the hearts of enthusiasts worldwide, with over 60,000 units sold in its previous generation. The M2 is popular for its exceptional performance and engaging driving dynamics.

The M2 model has gone through different changes and improvements during its production run. However, not all M2 model years are created equal. Each iteration of the M2 has its own unique characteristics and potential drawbacks. From the original M2 to the limited-run CS and the significantly improved Competition variant, every version of the M2 is distinct.

In the following sections, we highlight the BMW M2 years to avoid and discuss the potential pitfalls associated with certain model years to help you navigate the used car market with confidence. 

Which BMW M2 Years to Avoid?

To be frank, the BMW M2 doesn’t have an extensive reliability record. It doesn’t have too many complaints and known issues that could hurt its overall reliability. Many of these issues are also non-major in general. However, we’ve done our due diligence to highlight some of the known complaints and issues that may sway you from investing in an M2.

With that said, below are some of the BMW M2 years to avoid:

• 2016 BMW M2
• 2017 BMW M2
• 2018 BMW M2
• 2023 BMW M2

2016 BMW M2

Here at CoPilot, we generally advise buyers to steer clear or at least be wary of first production years due to teething issues. Unfortunately, that seems to be the case with the 2016 M2.

---

DOWNLOAD THE FREE APP

The CoPilot car shopping app is the smartest way to buy a car. Get a curated list of the best cars for sale in your area, as well as notifications if a similar vehicle is listed nearby at a lower price. CoPilot is the smartest way to shop for used cars. 

---

Gauge Lighting Issues

The 2016 BMW M2 has struggled with a significant lighting problem that has caused frustration and concern among its owners. Many have reported that the poor contrast of the gauges renders them nearly illegible in certain lighting conditions, such as during dusk, dawn, or when shadows from trees briefly obscure the instrument cluster. Wearing sunglasses only serves to worsen the issue, making it even more difficult to read the speedometer and tachometer.

This design flaw poses a serious safety risk, as drivers are forced to strain their eyes to see these critical gauges while operating the vehicle. One owner from Palatine, IL, USA, described the speedometer numbers as “gray on a gray background,” which makes it extremely challenging to read in overcast daytime conditions. As a result, drivers may unintentionally exceed the speed limit, as they struggle to interpret the readings on their instrument panel.

BMW has since addressed the problem in later models, but 2016-2017 M2 owners have been left to deal with the issue without a satisfactory resolution. The problem has become so widespread that dedicated threads on BMW enthusiast forums have emerged, with owners discussing the lighting issue and searching for potential solutions.

2017 BMW M2

As mentioned earlier, the 2017 model year shares the same, albeit minor, instrument gauge lighting problem as the 2016 M2.

Instrument Gauge Poor Contrast

There have been a lot of complaints from owners of the 2017 BMW M2 regarding the visibility of the instrument panel during the daytime. They have reported that seeing important dashboard information, such as speed and RPM readings in various lighting conditions, is a challenge. These conditions include overcast skies, shaded areas, and when wearing sunglasses.

As previously mentioned, the problem with the BMW 2017 models lies in the instrument cluster’s lack of sufficient backlighting, making it very difficult for drivers to read the gauges. This forces them to take their eyes off the road for longer than necessary, which is a significant safety concern. Although BMW has improved the 2018 models, they have not extended the same update to the 2017 models. This has left many drivers feeling frustrated with the oversight and worried about their safety while driving.

---

ARE BMWS RELIABLE?

The easiest way to approach the “are BMWs reliable” question is to favor the odds, an essential strategy if you’re shopping for a used BMW.

---

Potential Engine Problems

Although not exactly widespread, M2 owners have reported engine issues related to oil leaks. The valve cover and its gasket are prone to deterioration over time, which can lead to leaks. In many cases, the gasket starts to fail first, but when attempting to replace it, the plastic cover may crack due to the removal process. To avoid this, it’s recommended to replace both components at the same time.

Another area of concern is the rubber oil pan gasket, which is also susceptible to leaks. If you notice any signs of an oil leak, such as engine smoke, an illuminated oil light on the dashboard, engine overheating, or dark puddles beneath the engine, it’s best to address the issue quickly.

While these engine problems are not unique to the M2 and are relatively common among BMW vehicles, they can still be a cause for concern. Ignoring oil leaks can lead to more severe engine damage, which may result in costly repairs down the line.

2018 BMW M2

The 2018 model is still one of the BMW M2 years to avoid due to a different set of problems. At the top of its list of troubles is the faulty turn signals.

---

DO BMWS HOLD THEIR VALUE?

If you’re interested in a BMW, it’s critical to ask one question - do BMWs hold their value?

---

Turn Signal Malfunction

The 2018 BMW M2 has been known to experience issues with its turn signals, a problem that has become a common complaint among owners in various BMW communities. One of the most frequently reported problems is the malfunction of the rear right indicator, which can cause an intermittent warning message to appear on the dashboard. This issue can be frustrating for drivers, as it compromises their safety and prevents the car from passing its MOT.

In addition to the warning message, other symptoms of faulty turn signals in the M2 include rapidly blinking indicators, non-functioning turning light bulbs at the front or rear and constantly illuminated turn signal indicators. A variety of factors, such as a defective turn signal switch, a blown bulb, a malfunctioning flasher relay, or damaged wiring, can cause these issues.

These issues not only puts the driver and other road users at risk but also increases the likelihood of more severe and costly repairs down the line.

That wraps up our round up of the M2 years to avoid. Many of these issues are far from major, but are still worth knowing if you’re in the market for this luxury car.

---

---

Get a Curated List of the Best Used Cars Near You

The CoPilot car shopping app is the easiest way to buy a car. Tell us what you’re looking for and we’ll search the inventories of every dealership in your area to make you a personalized list of the best car listings in your area.

The best part? CoPilot is built using the same technology that dealerships use to buy and sell their inventories, so we have more info on each vehicle than competitors. CoPilot doesn’t work with dealerships, so there are no sponsored posts or other shady practices — just the most info on the best cars. Check out our About Us page to see how CoPilot works.